Arizona Geological Society

Welcome to the Arizona Geological Society

Fall 2016 Field Trip By Charles Ferguson


The only bad news to report from the Peach Spring Tuff field trip to northwestern Arizona in October, 2016 was that a couple of side-wall punctures killed two tires. One, at least, happened on the first afternoon during a scenic excursion down Sawmill Canyon in Kingman.  Here, some of the participants rightly complained that the rocks are too deeply weathered to appreciate petrographically. Adding to this frustration, the final stop of the day was at a City park where hammers are not allowed. Because of this, no one got a chance to collect decent samples of the main body of the Peach Spring Tuff. Realizing this need, two alternative stops have been added to the guide. The first is at the mouth of Sawmill Canyon where a quarry wall exposes fresh ignimbrite of that zone, and the second is the classic, monster road cut that looms over the west-bound lane of I-40 at Cook Canyon near old downtown Kingman. Good samples for teaching and/or research collections can be obtained at both of these stations, and by not taking the risky, shrapnel-ridden scenic drive down Sawmill Canyon, groups can save at least an hour on future trips.

Directions for the scenic drive are still in the guide where it is identified as a specialty excursion for those keen to familiarize themselves with the ignimbrite’s weathering profile and geomorphic expression.

For the rest of the trip, five significant questions / dissenting opinions were specifically addressed while completing the guide. The guide now includes a regional geologic map and cross-section. Special thanks to University of Arizona economic/bedrock geologists Max Larkin, Roy Grieg, Eric Seedorff, and Jon Spencer, Prescott professional geologist Don White, and Cal Tech geologist Joann Stock for their challenging and constructive input.

At “early bird” optional stop O-2 Paleoproterozoic gneiss in contact with Kessler’s (1976) Mesoproterozoic (1335 +/- 35 Ma Rb/Sr) coarse-grained K-feldspar megacrystic Holy Moses Granite produced an interesting discussion and well-founded dissenting opinion. As it turns out, even though much of the contact shows clear evidence of metasomatic overprint, it is also clear that the granite intrudes the gneiss.An interesting dissenting opinion regarding the origin of the Oatman epithermal gold district was offered by Eric Seedorff on the morning of the second day just prior to examining the classic Gold Road vein along old route US 66 just east of Oatman (Stop 10). Gold mineralization at Oatman clearly post-dates two phases of caldera-related alteration that are, by themselves, devoid of gold mineralization: first, a pervasive propylitic alteration of pre-caldera, dacitic/lacustrine rocks, and second, an advanced argillic alteration associated with a post-caldera, bi-modal granitic-monzonitic hypabyssal intrusive suite. Optimistically, one might suppose that the older alterations served to prepare the host rock for gold mineralization during emplacement of a suite of rhyolitic dikes and stocks ~ 1 million years after caldera formation. Eric suggested that gold mineralization might be totally unrelated to the caldera. A quick and dirty review of the literature inspired by a dissenting opinion to Eric’s suggestion (sent by to me after the trip by Don White) suggests that there is in fact a close, if not always direct, association between silicic calderas and epithermal gold mineralization world-wide. Certainly, there are places where low-sulfidation quartz-calcite-adularia +/- fluorite like the ones at Oatman have no connection with a caldera. How many of those however, might be like the mid-Cenozoic Akarca district in western Turkey where veins (Figure 3) remarkably similar to the Oatman veins, are hosted in a volcaniclastic conglomerate many 10s of km away from any similarly aged volcanic field? Since the veins at Akarca are now known to be truncated and carried in the hangingwall of a major detachment fault (Ferguson, Polat, and Akbayram, in progress), it is entirely possible that they may have been peripheral to a silicic caldera during mineralization.

The third significant question to be raised was again by Eric Seedroff who suggested that the Peach Spring Tuff’s absence in the volcanic pile around Oatman was the result of post-caldera uplift and erosion. The main reason it took so long to recognize that Thorson’s (1971) Alcyone caldera was source of the Peach Spring Tuff (as was astutely suggested by Thorson in the appendix of his dissertation) is that the ignimbrite is absent from the volcanic pile immediately east of the caldera. The guide suggests that pre-caldera uplift created a highland east of the caldera where the ignimbrite was never deposited, and to expand and explain this interpretation, the outflow sheet’s zero isopach line, based on mapping of the Mt Nutt quadrangle (Ferguson and Cook, 2017), is shown on Figure 2a of the guide. The ignimbrite near the zero edge consists of a condensed section of the uppermost zone(s) of the ignimbrite encased within a monotonous section of dacitic lava. Conglomerates that overlie the ignimbrite farther east contain sparse to zero clasts of the ignimbrite.

A dissenting view regarding the location of the cryptic, Peach Spring Tuff hiatus near the Gold Road vein (Stop 10) was brought up during a reprise of the field trip to a group from Cal Tech lead by Joann Stock. The best known exposure of the caldera margin along Times Gulch was visited at a Stop (11) that was skipped during the original trip because it would have required a short but strenuous hike. The skipped Stop 11 visits exposures of a sharp contact between the intracaldera Peach Spring Tuff and the Oatman andesite, the unit that supposedly underlies the Peach Spring Tuff-aged hiatus at the Gold Road vein stop (10). The contact at Stop 11, like the semi exposure of contact that was visited along the road during the original field trip farther down the canyon, is interpreted to be a northwest-facing buttress unconformity. Suppose the contact at Stop 11 is, instead, an intrusion of hypabyssal Oatman andesite into the intracaldera ignimbrite. This, I reason in an expanded discussion inserted into the revised guidebook, is possible but, based on stratigraphic relationships established in the Boundary Cone quad (Spencer et al. (2006) just to the south of the Oatman area, highly unlikely. Still, it is possible and the implications are intriguing since placing the “hiatus” at a lower interval might explain why the Oatman andesite is not present in the pre-Peach Spring Tuff “Snagletooth Volcanics” of the Sacramento Mts. The expanded discussion is also useful in that it emphasizes a fundamental difference between the caldera margins on either side of the Colorado River. In California, the caldera margin is a southeast-facing trap door mantled by a thick outflow of Peach Spring Tuff. In Arizona the margin is a scoured, highland rim devoid of outflow, bounded by a precipitous, west-facing escarpment.

The outline of a Pease et al.’s (1999) composite granodiorite-granite pluton of identical (18.8 Ma) age to the Peach Spring Tuff in the footwall of the Sacramento Mountains detachment (SMD) 30 km south-southwest of the main caldera fragment in Arizona is shown on Figure 2a of the new guide. Its location northeast of the tectonically dismembered segments of the caldera margin in the Sacramento Mts, and the lack of any known significant mid-Tertiary plutons in basement rocks to the southwest, constitute the two principal justifications for how the regional geologic cross-section shown in Figure 2b of the new guide was drawn. The cross-section, which had been rejected by three of the four reviewers of the original Ferguson et al. (2013) Geology manuscript, is regurgitated principally to fulfill the request of Jon Spencer, who asked to see an alternative to the rolling hinge model. The cross-section shows the pluton of Pease et al. (1999) as part of a sub-caldera mesozonal pluton. Jon remarked that the exposure of the low-angle fault visited at Stop 15, a scant 5 km south of the limit of his mapping in 1983, is one the best examples of a detachment fault that he has ever seen. Sue Beard, who wrote the one positive (and highly constructive) review of the aforementioned rejected manuscript, reproduced the 215 deg. slickenline lineation (she measured 216 deg) quoted for the fault at Stop 15 by Simpson et al. (1991).


References

Ferguson C. A., McIntosh, W. C., and Miller, C. F., Silver Creek caldera, 2013, The tectonically dismembered source of the Peach Spring Tuff: Geology, v. 41, p. 3-6.

Ferguson, C. A., and Cook, J. P., 2017, Geologic map of the Mt Nutt 7.5’ quadrangle, Mohave County, Arizona: Arizona Geological Survey Digital Geologic Map DGM-118, 1 sheet, 24,000 scale.

Kessler, E. J., 1976, Rubidium-strontium geochronolocy and trace element geochemistry of Precambrian rocks in the northern Hualapai Mountains, Mohave County, Arizona: Tucson, University of Arizona, M.S. thesis, 73 pp.

Pease, V., Foster, D., Wooden, J., Olivine’Sullivan, P., Argent, J., and Fanning, C., 1999, The northern Sacramento Mountains, southwestern United States: Part II, Exhumation history and detachment faulting, in Mac Niocaill, C., and Ryan, P. D., eds., Continental Tectonics: Geological Society of London Special Publication, v. 164, p. 199-237, doi:10.1144/GSL.SP.1999.164.01.11.

Simpson, C., Schweitzer, J., and Howard, K. A., 1991, A reinterpretation of the timing, position, and significance of part of the Sacramento Mountains detachment fault, southeastern California: GSA Bulletin, v. 103, p. 751-761.

Spencer, J. E., Ferguson, C. A., Pearthree, P. A., and Richard, S. M., 2006, Geologic map of the Boundary Cone 7.5’ quadrangle, Mohave County, Arizona: Arizona Geological Survey Map DGM-54, 2 sheets, 24,000 scale, 10 p. text. 

Thorson, J.P., 1971, Igneous petrology of the Oatman district, Mohave County, Arizona (Ph.D. thesis): University of California–Santa Barbara, 189 pp., 2 plates, 1:24,000 scale. 


AGS Digests Now Available On-line


Articles contained within the Arizona Geological Society Digests 1 through 22 are now available on-line at our publications page.  Our out-of-print Digests are available to the public, While our in-print Digests are only accessible to AGS members. 

Anyone who is interested in purchasing Printed Copies of In-Print AGS Digests can do so on-line or contact the AGS Secretary for more details.  Copies of current AGS Guidebooks and Digests are also for sale at a reduced price at AGS monthly dinner meetings.


Wulfenite in Arizona by Jan C. Rasmussen and Stanley B. Keith

Wulfenite from Red Cloud Mine, Trigo Mountains,

La Paz County, AZ

Jan Rasmussen and Stan Keith presented a paper on Wulfenite in Arizona to the Tucson Gem and Mineralogical Society on January 9, 2017. 

Wulfenite is a lead molybdate mineral, which is a oxidation product of primary galena.  It ranges from orange-yellow, honey-yellow, reddish-orange, grey, brown, olive-green to black in color.  Colorless varieties are rare.  It's color is dependent on elemental impurities of tungsten, calcium, vanadium, arsenic, chromium and titanium.

There are 275 identified occurrences of wulfenite localities in Arizona.  The best wulfenite specimens are commonly found in water courses/large open fillings located in Alkali-Calcic and Quartz Alkalic mining districts away from immediate lead source.

Here is a link a MP3 recording of the Wulfenite in Arizona presentation.


2016 J. Harold Courtright Scholarship Recipient

Bob Powell, head of the Arizona Geological Society's Scholarship committee awarded the J. Harold Courtright Scholarship to Daniel A. Favorito during the AGS December dinner meeting.  Anna Schuh and Philip McFarland, recipients of the M. Lee Allison Scholarship were unable to attend the December meeting and will be recognized for their achievements at our February 2017 dinner meeting.



Bob Powell presents Daniel Favorito the 2017 Courtright Scholarship

Daniel Favorito received his B.S. in Geology from the Richard Stockton College of New Jersey in 2014 and his M. S. in Geosciences from the University of Arizona in 2016.  He is currently pursuing a Ph.D. in Geoscicences at the U. of A.  His dissertation research involves studying the space-time relationships between Laramide contractional deformation and the formation of porphyry coppers in southeastern Arizona.


AZGS Discovers a New Large Earth Fissure in Southern Pinal County

Earth scientists from the Arizona Geological Survey have identified a fresh 2-mile long earth fissure approximate 10 miles south-southwest of Picacho Peak State Park. Located in the Tator Hills Fissure Study Area, this new fissure is oriented roughly north-south and ranges from up to 10 feet side and 25 to 30 feet deep.  Evidence suggest this earth fissure began to form between March 2013 and December 2014

AZGS and Arizona Department of Water Resources personnel prepared the first drone video of a fresh earth fissure in Arizona.

Earth fissures result from basin subsidence that accompanies extensive ground water withdrawal from the unconsolidated ground water aquifers within alluvial valleys of southern Arizona.


Earth fissures result from basin subsidence that accompanies extensive ground water withdrawal from the unconsolidated ground water aquifers within alluvial valleys of southern Arizona.


Will Wulfenite become
Arizona's State Mineral?


On February 10, 2017, the Arizona House voted 57-1 to make wulfenite Arizona's State Mineral.  A vote on this measure by the Arizona Senate is expected to occur during the week of February 28th.

Continued support is needed to get it through this crucial hurdle.  If it is passed by the Senate, it goes to the Governor's office to be signed in law.


February 2017 Newsletter





February 2017 Sponsor

Our 2016 Dinner Meeting Sponsors

        

              

   



The Arizona Geological Society is grateful for our Sponsors, who help us offset the increasing costs of our dinner meetings and other activities of the society.


For Cancellations or Changes Please Contact

Upcoming events - Register Here!

07 Mar 2017 6:00 PM • Sheraton, 5151 E Grant Rd. (& Rosemont), Tucson AZ 85712
04 Apr 2017 6:00 PM • Sheraton, 5151 E Grant Rd. (& Rosemont), Tucson AZ 85712
02 May 2017 6:00 PM • Sheraton, 5151 E Grant Rd. (& Rosemont), Tucson AZ 85712



Student Dinner Sponsor for 2017

Arizona Geological Society is grateful to Freeport-McMoRan, Inc. for their generous support of our student members!


Freeport-McMoRan is sponsoring student dinners for the 2017 AGS monthly meetings.


2016 M. Lee Allison Scholarship Recipients

Recipients of the 2016 M. Lee Allison Scholarship, Anna Schuh and Philip McFarland were recognized at the February dinner meeting.


Anna Schuh

Anna Schuh is a senior in the University of Arizona Honors College, where she is pursuing concurrently a Bachelor of Science in Geosciences, a Bachelor of Business Administration in Management Information Systems, and a Minor in German Language.  To broaden her geologic experience and expand her cultural awareness, Anna spent a semester abroad at the University of Canterbury in New Zealand and participated in their geologic field camp.


Philip McFarland

Philip McFarland graduated from the University of Arizona in 2013, receiving his B.S. in Applied Mathematics with a Minor in Geoscicences.  He is now pursuing his Ph.D. in Geosciences at the University of Arizona.  His dissertation research focuses on using space geodesy (GPS and InSAR) to measure active deformation in the Puna Plateau region of the Central Andes, where active subduction of the Nazca Plate is accompanied by shortening of the South American crust.


2017 Tucson Gem and Mineral Show

The 2017 Tucson Gem and Mineral Show was held at the Tucson Convention Center on February 9-12th, 2017.  Here are some photos Cori Hoag and Jan Rasmussen took at the show.

TGMS Show Poster with Native Copper



Tourmaline and Quartz from Pederneira Mine, Minas Gerais, Brazil


Cerussite, Flux Mine, Harshaw District, Santa Cruz Co., Arizona


Malachite - Lavender Pit, Bisbee, Arizona


Cuprite, Ray Mine, Pinal County, Arizona


Efforts to Transfer the
Mineral Museum to the
University of Arizona


U of A's Tim Bee at the podium and Kimberly Espy waiting for her opportunity to throw U of A support behind SB1415

Arizona Senate bill SB 1415, finalizing the permanent transfer of the Polly Rosenbaum Building and Arizona Mining & Mineral Museum collection to the University of Arizona, was passed 9/0/1 by the Arizona Senate Appropriations Committee on Tuesday, February 14, 2017. The U of A sent two heavy hitters, Tim Bee and Kimberly Espy, to voice their support for this bill. Both spoke keenly about the U of A’s interest in re-establishing a museum in the Rosenbaum Building.

In a related matter, SB1184 also passed the Arizona Senate Appropriation Committee.  It provides $941,000 of operating funds for the Arizona Geological Survey in FY 2018.  The survey got a scare as there was an amendment to reduce its funding to $500,000.  Fortunately, Committee Chair Lasko withdrew the amendment.

There are several more hurdles before the AZGS gets the badly needed funds it requires to continue core services it performs for the citizens of Arizona.  However, today’s appropriations vote was a big step forward.

Arizona Geological Society member are urged to express their support for these bills to their elected representatives.



Copyright © 2013 Arizona Geological Society
                                   Contact: info@arizonageologicalsoc.org
Powered by Wild Apricot Membership Software